Azaria Kidane London Politica Azaria Kidane London Politica

Brazil-China: Trade Relations and their Impact on Commodities

 

Brazilian President Lula's recent trip to China has stoked tensions between Brazil and the West. From both a geopolitical and financial point of view, Lula’s actions surrounding the trip represent a marked change from his predecessor Bolsonaro. Where Bolsonaro had backed ally President Trump’s aggressive rhetoric on foreign policy, Lula is not only trying to reestablish Brazil’s role in global diplomacy, but is also toeing a more neutral line in the developing cold war between China and the US. Lula seems to be aligning himself with the other BRICS (Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa) nations, but due to rivalries between the member nations, it is the bilateral economic deals that will have a more visible effect on the world, rather than empty foreign policy promises. 

Alongside 240 Brazilian business leaders, Lula headed to China for the inauguration of former Brazilian President Dilma Roussef as head of the New Development Bank, a multilateral development bank established by the BRICS to help fund infrastructure projects in developing countries. This set the financial tone for the rest of his visit, in which 15 deals worth about $10 billion were signed between Brazil and China. China has long been Brazil’s largest export market and Lula wants to leverage this relationship to help with the reindustrialization of Brazil. With US companies leaving Brazil, the symbolism of Ford seeking to sell its plant to BYD cannot be understated. This coupled with talks between BRICS to dethrone the dollar as the currency for international trade will come as a blow to Biden, though it is unlikely that China will want the Yuan to become an international currency. Lula’s comments surrounding the Russo-Ukrainian war sparked more controversy in the West after he offered to join China in mediating peace talks while also placing partial blame for the conflict on the US. 

Overall, Lula’s visit is most surprising as it marks a shift in Brazilian foreign policy, though this is only surprising when looking at the policies of his predecessor. Indeed, Lula is known to be a staunch leftist and had started cultivating a relationship with China in his previous presidency, so we can assume that this relationship will only be strengthened under his administration. President Xi has made it clear that Brazil is a key part of his plans of challenging US global hegemony, and this is shown by bilateral trade increasing by 10.1% from 2021 to 2022. A key commodity being sold by Brazil is beef, as China has a huge demand for it with 55% of their imports coming from Brazil and 10% of Brazil’s sales being to China. However, Brazil is also a key part of the iron, soybean, and crude petroleum markets. In addition to this, Brazil was the single largest recipient of Chinese FDI in 2021. This is part of Xi’s plan of integrating Brazil into the Belt and Road initiative, to increase China’s influence in Latin America, so we can expect trade to grow in coming years. 

The markets for each of Brazil’s main commodities, beef, soybeans, and crude petroleum could change drastically by the end of the year. Both beef and soybean sales are interconnected. Soybeans are instrumental for feeding beef cattle with cattle feed making up 18% of soybean sales in the US and 52% of the oil gathered from soybeans are used in the food industry. With growing demand for beef from China opening up, we can expect beef sales to increase through restaurants reaching pre-pandemic levels of demand and pushing soybean prices up as restaurants need more oil for frying food, while farmers will need more soybeans to feed growing cattle numbers. While some feared stricter controls on cattle rearing in the Amazon with the election of a left leaning President, Lula has been unwilling to change his predecessor's profitable policies. While Lula has talked about placing people and nature in front of profits, this philosophy has not yet reached the agricultural sector, but this does not necessarily mean it will enjoy projection for the rest of his term. For now the only thing which has stopped the flow of Brazilian beef has been cases of mad cow disease, but suspensions were normally lifted within a few months of being placed.

Iron ore makes up the largest portion of Brazil’s exports and its price shifts are harder to predict. In the short term, prices will increase as China opens back up. As it eases its coronavirus policy and its real estate sector gradually recovers, it is likely that demand for iron will increase from Brazil’s main trading partner. However, as the markets recover their supplies from India and Brazil, it is likely by the end of the year that prices could decrease. There is even the chance that Russian and Ukrainian supplies flood back into the market, which could drastically change the price of iron ore but it is unclear if a peace settlement can be reached anytime soon.

Read More